Sustainable Hybrid Document-Routed Retrieval for financial RAG: Resolving the robustness-precision trade-off

Counts differ because each database indexes a different set of publications. We treat OpenAlex as the canonical count; Google Scholar is not shown (no API, and crawling it violates its ToS).

Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) systems for financial document QA typically follow a chunk-based paradigm: documents are split into fragments, embedded, and retrieved by similarity. In structurally homogeneous corpora such as regulatory filings, this suffers from cross-document chunk confusion. Semantic File Routing (SFR), which uses LLM structured output to route queries to whole documents, reduces catastrophic failures but sacrifices targeted-chunk precision. We identify this robustness-precision trade-off on the FinDER benchmark (1,500 queries across five groups): SFR achieves higher average scores (6.45 vs. 6.02) and fewer failures (10.3% vs. 22.5%), while chunk-based retrieval (CBR) yields more perfect answers (13.8% vs. 8.5%). To resolve it, we propose Hybrid Document-Routed Retrieval (HDRR), a two-stage architecture that uses SFR as a document filter followed by chunk retrieval scoped to the identified document(s), eliminating cross-document confusion while preserving chunk precision. HDRR achieves the best performance on every metric: an average score of 7.54 (25.2% above CBR, 16.9% above SFR), a 6.4% failure rate, 67.7% correctness (+18.7 pp over CBR), and a 20.1% perfect-answer rate (+6.3 pp over CBR, +11.6 pp over SFR), simultaneously attaining the lowest failure rate and highest precision across all five groups. Beyond accuracy, HDRR is also the most efficient of the high-quality systems: it preserves CBR's compact per-query token budget (~5K-15K, an order of magnitude below SFR's ~50K-200K), incurs no indexing-time LLM spend (versus the one-time ~$100 cost of contextual indexing), and uses fewer per-query LLM calls than self-correcting agentic baselines, translating directly to lower API spend and inference-time energy at deployment scale.